10 Questions to Ask Before Choosing a Surrogacy Agency
Choosing a surrogacy agency is a big decision, and it shouldn’t be one you make on a gut feeling alone. Whether you’re an Intended Parent hoping to grow your family, or you’re a woman thinking seriously about becoming a gestational surrogate, the agency you pick will shape your whole experience. They’re the ones coordinating with your medical team, your legal team, your escrow company, and honestly, a lot of your peace of mind along the way.
There are so many agencies out there, and they don’t all operate the same way. Before you sign anything, here are 10 questions worth asking, no matter which side of the journey you’re on.
1. How long has the agency been matching surrogates and Intended Parents?
This one’s simple: experience shows. An agency that’s been doing this for years has usually already made the mistakes, learned from them, and built real relationships with fertility clinics, attorneys and other surrogacy professionals along the way. Don’t be shy about asking how many matches they’ve supported and what those journeys actually looked like.
2. What does the screening process look like for surrogates?
A good agency screens carefully. That means medical history reviews, psychological evaluations, home studies, background checks, the whole picture. This is what keeps everyone safe. If you’re an Intended Parent, you should feel confident that every surrogate you’re matched with has genuinely been vetted. And if you’re considering becoming a surrogate, a thorough process is actually a good sign that the agency is taking your health seriously too.
3. How does the agency match Intended Parents and surrogates?
Matching is where the relationship starts, so it matters more than people expect. Ask how they think about compatibility. Communication style, values, expectations around contact during and after the pregnancy, comfort levels around harder topics like termination and selective reduction. An agency that puts real thought into this tends to set up relationships that actually last.
4. What kind of support is offered throughout the journey?
Here’s the thing: surrogacy is a medical and legal process on paper, but it doesn’t feel that way when you’re living it. Is there a dedicated case manager? Access to counseling? A community of other surrogates or Intended Parents to talk to when things get hard, or when you just want someone who gets it? At Paying It Forward Surrogacy, this kind of hands-on support is the whole point. Nobody should feel like they’re figuring this out alone.
5. How are legal and financial matters handled?
Contracts, escrow accounts, compensation schedules. Ask which attorneys the agency works with and whether funds are held by third-parties in escrow accounts. If an agency gets vague or evasive here, take that seriously.
6. What are the total costs, and what’s included?
Intended Parents, get the full breakdown before you commit. Agency fees, surrogate compensation, medical costs, legal fees, and anything that might come up later. Surrogates: Ask how and when you’ll actually be paid, and what happens financially if the journey ends up taking longer or is more complicated than expected.
7. How does the agency handle communication between surrogates and Intended Parents?
Not every match wants the same kind of relationship. Some Intended Parents and Surrogates want frequent updates and check-ins. Others prefer more space and structure. Ask how the agency helps set those expectations early, and what they do if things don’t quite line up once the journey is underway.
8. What happens if something doesn’t go as planned?
Journeys don’t always go in a straight line. A failed transfer, a change in circumstances, a match that doesn’t work out. Ask directly how the agency handles these moments. You want to hear a real answer here, not a reassurance.
9. Are there reviews or testimonials from past surrogates or Intended Parents?
Because of privacy, most agencies can’t connect you directly with past clients, and that’s normal, not a red flag. What you can ask for is honest reviews and testimonials, whether that’s on Google, social media, or the agency’s own website. Look for specifics, not just glowing one-liners. Real experiences tend to mention the details: how communication was handled, how support felt during hard moments, whether the agency followed through on what they promised.
10. Does the agency’s mission and values align with yours?
This is the one people sometimes skip, and it shouldn’t be. Ask about the agency’s founding story and why they do this work. At Paying It Forward Surrogacy, that story is personal. Everything we do is built around compassion, honesty, and the belief that every family and every Surrogate deserves to be treated with real care, not processed like a file number.
There’s No One “Right” Agency, But There Is a Right Fit
The best agency for you is the one that answers your questions directly, treats you as an individual, and has the track record to back it up. Take your time with this decision. Ask hard questions. Notice how they make you feel when you ask them.
If you’re an Intended Parent ready to grow your family, or you’re exploring what it means to become a surrogate, we’d love to talk with you. Reach out to Paying It Forward Surrogacy to start the conversation.
Ready to take the next step?
